Introduction the year 2009 marked 10 years since south africas affirmative action aa legislation of 1998 took effect. Unpacking the affirmative action equation from a constitutional perspective. Republic ofsouth africa affirmative action policy affirmative action policy version 1. Affirmative action in south africa does more harm than. Historically and internationally, support for affirmative action has sought to achieve goals such as bridging inequalities in employment and pay, increasing access to education. The context, root causes and methods of redress differ across countries, and various terms such as positive discrimination, positive action measures and others have been used, but affirmative action seems to have gained the most traction in international discourse. Affirmative action in south africas privatesector, at st. Sa affirmative action to be challenged at the united. Labour republic of south africa page home about us contacts services media desk tenders vacancies site map basic guide to affirmative action affirmative action ensures that qualified people from designated groups have equal opportunities in the workplace. What south africans really think about racism and affirmative.
Affirmative action has been practiced in all three countries since the early 1990s, but there. Mar 19, 2010 affirmative action wasnt invented in south africa. South africa sa has a rich history of racial divisions that affected people of colour african, coloured, and indian people at all levels of the society, be it socially or in employment. The focus of this article is affirmative action to put some of this aspiration into practice, looking at interventions used by universities in kenya, uganda and tanzania to enhance womens access to university education. The article draws attention to two dominant discoursesthe first being that of the patriotic university, and the second being that of the global university. Unfair affirmative action in south african historiography fransjohan pretorius department of historical and heritage studies university of pretoria 0002 pretoria i have some concern that the afrikaner does not figure in the new history books on south african history, except as the scapegoat and the villain. Historical context of affirmative action in south africa historically, in societies all over the globe, various groups of people, usually minorities classified according to traits like gender, cast, ethnicity, and religion are discriminated against, resulting in lack of access to resources.
Some issues in affirmative action in higher education. Most countries expect their armed forces to be broadly representative of the populace with respect to race, ethnic composition, social class, religion and gender. One approach is representivity, which is another word for. Racial inequality and affirmative action in malaysia and. Pdf on jan 1, 2010, rulof burger and others published affirmative action in south africa. Kanya adam recently wrote her doctoral dissertation on, the politics of redress. The term affirmative action was first used in the united states in executive order no. Affirmative action in south africa the new york times. According to the phrase was coined in the united states to refer to policies that take race, ethnicity, physical disability or sex into consideration in an attempt to promote equal oppor. This option is usually reserved for specific minority demographics that suffered discrimination in previous generations. Racial inequality and affirmative action in malaysia and south africa. South africa is still coping with the aftermath of apartheid and a. Affirmative action was a mechanism for black empowerment, the term used to ensure higher levels of economic, educational, cultural and political attainment for. Sa affirmative action to be challenged at the united nations.
Pdf this paper examines affirmative action in malaysia and south africa, two regimes. When, twenty years ago, south africa became a democratic state, the framers of the new constitutional order were confronted with a country beset by the divisions caused by. Affirmative action in south africa must be ended immediately. In south africa, does affirmative action have a place in a. It was developed and enforced for the first time by president johnson. However, the first democratic elections took place 14 years ago and yet affirmative action policies have strengthened. Basic guide to affirmative action department of labour. The thesis outlines affirmative action in the three key jurisdictions noting. The purpose of this article is to attempt a surfacing of the assumptions and discourses surrounding the affirmative action debate in higher education in south africa. Affirmative action, socioeconomic challenges and the effect.
Affirmative action programmes mustbeintegrated withotherhumanresource management anddevelopment practices, especially themanagement ofdiversity. A new report by the institute of race relations irr reveals the opinions of south africans of all races when it comes to issues of racism and affirmative action. Kennedy on 6 march 1961, which included a provision that government contractors take affirmative action to ensure that applicants are employed, and employees are treated fairly during employment, without regard to their race, creed, color, or national origin. Equity plan within the latitude permitted by the employment equity act uses targets to. Pretoriuslegal evaluation of affirmative action in south africa 1. Her academic specialization includes international relations, comparative politics, and comparative ethnic and race relations. Dilemmas of affirmative action in south africa anu press. Unfair affirmative action in south african historiography. The report was submitted eight years after the deadline. View academics in affirmative action in south africa on academia.
Affirmative action and the black women in south africa. The white paper on affirmative action in the public service will also be available in south sotho, zulu, tsonga and afrikaans on the internet at. Affirmative action in south africa does more harm than good. In terms of the first idea, the argument is made that the university.
In south africa, as in all country cases with affirmative action programmes, the experience is notoriously uniformly negative. Dec 01, 2010 celia dugger reports on how affirmative action policy at the university of cape town has turned into a national debate on how to erase racial divides that linger 16 years after the end of apartheid. One of the enduring legacies of apartheid is the extreme socioeconomic disparities that emerged in the south african society. Imperative, content and context of affirmative action. Years after implementing affirmative action in south africa, perceptions of. Access, gender equity and affirmative action in all three countries affirmative action has been used to increase womens access to university. The lesson that should be gleaned from this is that affirmative action policies should be totally and unreservedly repealed. An overview was given of how affirmative action for blacks and women in south africa in fact marginalizes black women. Historical context of affirmative action in south africa historically, in societies all over the globe, various groups of people, usually minorities classified according to traits like gender, cast, ethnicity, and religion are discriminated against, resulting in lack of access to resources, education etc.
Affirmative action in south africa is remedial, whereas in the united states it facilitates free speech, meritocracy and the marketplace. Introduction a major legislative development in south africa took place with the coming into effect of the employment equity act. South africa is still coping with the aftermath of apartheid and a lingering educational. In this post, dr max price, vicechancellor of the university of cape town, reflects upon the use of race as a marker for disadvantage and redress in south africa.
Democratic alliance leader, helen zille, has moved to classify affirmative action in south africa into four distinct approaches. Fears are expressed such as the lowering of standards, new kinds of. In its tumultuous 48year history, affirmative action has been both praised and pilloried as an answer to racial inequality. Celia dugger reports on how affirmative action policy at the university of cape town has turned into a national debate on how to erase racial divides that linger 16 years after the end of apartheid. It is morally and economically incumbent on policymakers to eliminate such a harmful measure. Affirmative action and the skills problems are discussed in more detail later. This foreword is brought to you for free and open access by the law journals at smu scholar. The concern, particularly with respect to the officer corps as leaders of the armed forces, is that an unrepresentative defence force may pose a threat to the principle of civil supremacy over the military. Pdf affirmative action in malaysia and south africa. Wider working paper 201666 affirmative action policies and.
Basic guide to affirmative action south africa aapf. The paper also sketches the accountability, monitoring and reporting responsibilities of various players within affirmative action programmes. Affirmative action does not kill babies article bogdan tagdiv 12 jun 2014 the subtext that black people are incompetent is widespread and racist and must be addressed, writes nikiwe bikitsha. After the first democratic election in south africa in 1994, the new democratic government harnessed all its resources towards establishing a nonracial society based on a constitution that embodies equal rights. South africa introduced affirmative action in the employment equity act, 55 of 1998. Affirmative action is an initiative adopted by the south african government, which seeks to correct the imbalance of wealth and provide opportunities to the people who were adversely affected as a result of the apartheid regime.
Wider working paper 201666 affirmative action policies. It is thus opportune to take stock, not only of the. Trade union solidaritys campaign to challenge the governments implementation of affirmative action at the united nations has gained momentum following the south african governments submission of a report on the elimination of racial discrimination in south africa to the united nations. The latitude to take up this position is created by the uncertainties and ambiguities of the governing law. The policies, although implemented for an admirable purpose, have done the economy and moral of the countrys citizens more harm than good. Tokyo sexwale, former premier of gauteng, said that malaysia. Academics in affirmative action in south africa academia. Affirmative action was introduced to counter the effects of apartheid. Years after implementing affirmative action in south africa, perceptions of its impact or even. Legal evaluation of affirmative action in south africa. Affirmative action policies are also key elements in addressing gender imbalances at the workplace which a characteristic in most african countries.
The implementation of affirmative action policy within the pretoria district of the south african police service by paulus hlongwane submitted in accordance with the requirements for the degree of master of administration in the subject public administration at the university of south africa supervisor. Eric ej937032 some issues in affirmative action in. Education in south africa is a mess, as a recent report highlights, and government should make ensuring that black students are given the best possible education a priority if it wants to see a. Throughout its report to the committee, the south african government proclaims its. Following the us supreme courts decision last week in fisher the oxhrh will be running a series of posts that offer international perspectives on affirmative action. Affirmative action, gender equity and university admissions. May 10, 2011 universities in south africa are wrestling with an issue familiar to many americans. Affirmative action refers to a body of policies and procedures designed to eliminate discrimination against marginalized groups including ethnic minorities, and. Affirmative action in south africa repository home. The latitude to take up this position is created by the uncertainties and ambiguities of the. Affirmative action, socioeconomic challenges and the. South african police service employment equity plan numerical. Affirmative action policies in south africa and other countries have been designed to address inequity and discrimination, and to manage a wide range of diversity in all spheres of life, particularly after the end of apartheid in 1994.
Professor robert pollin this dissertation examines racial inequality and affirmative action in malaysia and. Lessons on affirmative action from south african employment law grete s. Universities in south africa are wrestling with an issue familiar to many americans. Affirmative action, refers to a set of policies that support members of disadvantaged groups that have previously suffered discrimination and may continue to in such areas as education, employment, or housing. In the early days of affirmative action malaysia was held up as the model of affirmative action by south africa.
The second reason why affirmative action, or racist preferentialism as it should more accurately be called, should cease to exist in south africa is because it represents a socially divisive policy that creates a sense that economic success is a zerosum game wherein if one group loses, the other one necessarily gains. The term affirmative action was first introduced by president kennedy in 1961 as a method of redressing discrimination that had persisted in spite of civil rights laws and constitutional guarantees. Towards a definition of affirmative action in south africa at the outset i intend to distance myself from any hard and fast definition of the concept of affirmative action. The definition of the problem influences the solution. Her academic specialization includes international relations, comparative. Affirmative action in south africa refers to policies that take factors including race, colour, religion, sex or national origin into consideration in order to benefit an underrepresented group, usually as a means to counter the effects of a history of discrimination. Affirmative action policies in south africa and other countries have been designed to address inequity and discrimination, and to manage a wide range of diversity in all spheres of life.
885 549 897 467 1502 1268 121 293 279 923 8 1227 388 1628 1548 1429 1556 1678 1313 1420 174 107 1130 240 430 811 1646 1356 1094 1347 1131 1079 443 905 1359 1173 205 1037 892 748 271 68 1163 555 1152 815 1187